openvidu-server: bug fixes for automatic stop of recordings

openvidu-server/src/main/java/io/openvidu/server/kurento/core/KurentoSessionManager.java

@@ -176,11 +176,9 @@ public class KurentoSessionManager extends SessionManager {
 			if (remainingParticipants.isEmpty()) {
 				if (openviduConfig.isRecordingModuleEnabled()
 						&& MediaMode.ROUTED.equals(session.getSessionProperties().mediaMode())
-						&& (this.recordingManager.sessionIsBeingRecordedIndividual(sessionId)
+						&& (this.recordingManager.sessionIsBeingRecorded(sessionId))) {
-								|| (this.recordingManager.sessionIsBeingRecordedComposed(sessionId)
+					// Start countdown to stop recording. Will be aborted if a Publisher starts
-										&& this.recordingManager.sessionIsBeingRecordedOnlyAudio(sessionId)))) {
+					// before timeout
-					// Start countdown to stop recording if INDIVIDUAL mode or COMPOSED audio-only
-					// (will be aborted if a Publisher starts before timeout)
 					log.info(
 							"Last participant left. Starting {} seconds countdown for stopping recording of session {}",
 							this.openviduConfig.getOpenviduRecordingAutostopTimeout(), sessionId);
@@ -192,25 +190,13 @@ public class KurentoSessionManager extends SessionManager {
 				}
 			} else if (remainingParticipants.size() == 1 && openviduConfig.isRecordingModuleEnabled()
 					&& MediaMode.ROUTED.equals(session.getSessionProperties().mediaMode())
-					&& this.recordingManager.sessionIsBeingRecordedComposed(sessionId)
+					&& this.recordingManager.sessionIsBeingRecorded(sessionId)
-					&& !this.recordingManager.sessionIsBeingRecordedOnlyAudio(sessionId)
 					&& ProtocolElements.RECORDER_PARTICIPANT_PUBLICID
 							.equals(remainingParticipants.iterator().next().getParticipantPublicId())) {
-				if (RecordingMode.ALWAYS.equals(session.getSessionProperties().recordingMode())) {
+				// Start countdown
-					// Immediately stop recording when last real participant left if
+				log.info("Last participant left. Starting {} seconds countdown for stopping recording of session {}",
-					// RecordingMode.ALWAYS
+						this.openviduConfig.getOpenviduRecordingAutostopTimeout(), sessionId);
-					log.info("Last participant left. Stopping recording for session {}", sessionId);
+				recordingManager.initAutomaticRecordingStopThread(session);
-					recordingManager.stopRecording(session, null, reason);
-					evictParticipant(session.getParticipantByPublicId(ProtocolElements.RECORDER_PARTICIPANT_PUBLICID),
-							null, null, "EVICT_RECORDER");
-				} else if (RecordingMode.MANUAL.equals(session.getSessionProperties().recordingMode())) {
-					// Start countdown to stop recording if RecordingMode.MANUAL (will be aborted if
-					// a Publisher starts before timeout)
-					log.info(
-							"Last participant left. Starting {} seconds countdown for stopping recording of session {}",
-							this.openviduConfig.getOpenviduRecordingAutostopTimeout(), sessionId);
-					recordingManager.initAutomaticRecordingStopThread(session);
-				}
 			}
 		}
 
@@ -300,11 +286,11 @@ public class KurentoSessionManager extends SessionManager {
 				&& session.getActivePublishers() == 0) {
 			if (RecordingMode.ALWAYS.equals(session.getSessionProperties().recordingMode())
 					&& !recordingManager.sessionIsBeingRecorded(session.getSessionId())) {
-				// Insecure session recording
+				// Start automatic recording for sessions configured with RecordingMode.ALWAYS
 				new Thread(() -> {
 					recordingManager.startRecording(session,
 							new RecordingProperties.Builder().name("")
-									.outputMode(io.openvidu.java.client.Recording.OutputMode.COMPOSED)
+									.outputMode(session.getSessionProperties().defaultOutputMode())
 									.recordingLayout(session.getSessionProperties().defaultRecordingLayout())
 									.customLayout(session.getSessionProperties().defaultCustomLayout()).build());
 				}).start();
@@ -313,7 +299,7 @@ public class KurentoSessionManager extends SessionManager {
 				// Abort automatic recording stop (user published before timeout)
 				log.info("Participant {} published before timeout finished. Aborting automatic recording stop",
 						participant.getParticipantPublicId());
-				boolean stopAborted = recordingManager.abortAutomaticRecordingStopThread(session.getSessionId());
+				boolean stopAborted = recordingManager.abortAutomaticRecordingStopThread(session);
 				if (stopAborted) {
 					log.info("Automatic recording stopped succesfully aborted");
 				} else {

openvidu-server/src/main/java/io/openvidu/server/recording/service/RecordingManager.java

@@ -200,7 +200,7 @@ public class RecordingManager {
 			recording = this.singleStreamRecordingService.stopRecording(session, recording, reason);
 			break;
 		}
-		this.abortAutomaticRecordingStopThread(session.getSessionId());
+		this.abortAutomaticRecordingStopThread(session);
 		return recording;
 	}
 
@@ -260,21 +260,6 @@ public class RecordingManager {
 		return (this.sessionsRecordings.get(sessionId) != null);
 	}
 
-	public boolean sessionIsBeingRecordedIndividual(String sessionId) {
-		Recording rec = this.sessionsRecordings.get(sessionId);
-		return (rec != null && io.openvidu.java.client.Recording.OutputMode.INDIVIDUAL.equals(rec.getOutputMode()));
-	}
-
-	public boolean sessionIsBeingRecordedComposed(String sessionId) {
-		Recording rec = this.sessionsRecordings.get(sessionId);
-		return (rec != null && io.openvidu.java.client.Recording.OutputMode.COMPOSED.equals(rec.getOutputMode()));
-	}
-
-	public boolean sessionIsBeingRecordedOnlyAudio(String sessionId) {
-		Recording rec = this.sessionsRecordings.get(sessionId);
-		return (rec != null && !rec.hasVideo());
-	}
-
 	public Recording getStartedRecording(String recordingId) {
 		return this.startedRecordings.get(recordingId);
 	}
@@ -363,26 +348,46 @@ public class RecordingManager {
 			log.info("Stopping recording {} after {} seconds wait (no publisher published before timeout)", recordingId,
 					this.openviduConfig.getOpenviduRecordingAutostopTimeout());
 
-			this.stopRecording(null, recordingId, "automaticStop");
+			if (this.automaticRecordingStopThreads.remove(session.getSessionId()) != null) {
-			this.automaticRecordingStopThreads.remove(session.getSessionId());
+				if (session.getParticipants().size() == 0 || (session.getParticipants().size() == 1
-
+						&& session.getParticipantByPublicId(ProtocolElements.RECORDER_PARTICIPANT_PUBLICID) != null)) {
-			if (session.getParticipants().size() == 0 || (session.getParticipants().size() == 1
+					// Close session if there are no participants connected (except for RECORDER).
-					&& session.getParticipantByPublicId(ProtocolElements.RECORDER_PARTICIPANT_PUBLICID) != null)) {
+					// This code won't be executed only when some user reconnects to the session
-				// Close session if there are no participants connected (except for RECORDER).
+					// but never publishing (publishers automatically abort this thread)
-				// This code won't be executed only when some user reconnects to the session
+					log.info("Closing session {} after automatic stop of recording {}", session.getSessionId(),
-				// but never publishing (publishers automatically abort this thread)
+							recordingId);
-				sessionManager.closeSessionAndEmptyCollections(session, "automaticStop");
+					sessionManager.closeSessionAndEmptyCollections(session, "automaticStop");
-				sessionManager.showTokens();
+					sessionManager.showTokens();
+				} else {
+					this.stopRecording(null, recordingId, "automaticStop");
+				}
+			} else {
+				// This code is reachable if there already was an automatic stop of a recording
+				// caused by not user publishing within timeout after recording started, and a
+				// new automatic stop thread was started by last user leaving the session
+				log.warn("Recording {} was already automatically stopped by a previous thread", recordingId);
 			}
 
 		}, this.openviduConfig.getOpenviduRecordingAutostopTimeout(), TimeUnit.SECONDS);
 		this.automaticRecordingStopThreads.putIfAbsent(session.getSessionId(), future);
 	}
 
-	public boolean abortAutomaticRecordingStopThread(String sessionId) {
+	public boolean abortAutomaticRecordingStopThread(Session session) {
-		ScheduledFuture<?> future = this.automaticRecordingStopThreads.remove(sessionId);
+		ScheduledFuture<?> future = this.automaticRecordingStopThreads.remove(session.getSessionId());
 		if (future != null) {
-			return future.cancel(false);
+			boolean cancelled = future.cancel(false);
+			if (session.getParticipants().size() == 0 || (session.getParticipants().size() == 1
+					&& session.getParticipantByPublicId(ProtocolElements.RECORDER_PARTICIPANT_PUBLICID) != null)) {
+				// Close session if there are no participants connected (except for RECORDER).
+				// This code will only be executed if recording is manually stopped during the
+				// automatic stop timeout, so the session must be also closed
+				log.info(
+						"Ongoing recording of session {} was explicetly stopped within timeout for automatic recording stop. Closing session",
+						session.getSessionId());
+				sessionManager.closeSessionAndEmptyCollections(session, "automaticStop");
+				sessionManager.showTokens();
+			}
+			return cancelled;
 		} else {
 			return true;
 		}

openvidu-server/src/main/java/io/openvidu/server/recording/service/RecordingService.java

@@ -54,6 +54,17 @@ public abstract class RecordingService {
 	 * store Recording entity)
 	 */
 	protected void generateRecordingMetadataFile(Recording recording) {
+		String folder = this.openviduConfig.getOpenViduRecordingPath() + recording.getId();
+		boolean newFolderCreated = this.fileWriter.createFolderIfNotExists(folder);
+
+		if (newFolderCreated) {
+			log.info(
+					"New folder {} created. This means the recording started for a session with no publishers or no media type compatible publishers",
+					folder);
+		} else {
+			log.info("Folder {} already existed. Some publisher is already being recorded", folder);
+		}
+
 		String filePath = this.openviduConfig.getOpenViduRecordingPath() + recording.getId() + "/"
 				+ RecordingManager.RECORDING_ENTITY_FILE + recording.getId();
 		String text = recording.toJson().toString();

openvidu-server/src/main/java/io/openvidu/server/recording/service/SingleStreamRecordingService.java

@@ -58,7 +58,6 @@ import io.openvidu.server.kurento.core.KurentoParticipant;
 import io.openvidu.server.kurento.endpoint.PublisherEndpoint;
 import io.openvidu.server.recording.RecorderEndpointWrapper;
 import io.openvidu.server.recording.Recording;
-import io.openvidu.server.utils.CommandExecutor;
 
 public class SingleStreamRecordingService extends RecordingService {
 
@@ -90,7 +89,6 @@ public class SingleStreamRecordingService extends RecordingService {
 
 		final int activePublishers = session.getActivePublishers();
 		final CountDownLatch recordingStartedCountdown = new CountDownLatch(activePublishers);
-		int incompatibleMediaTypePublishers = 0;
 
 		for (Participant p : session.getParticipants()) {
 			if (p.isStreaming()) {
@@ -102,7 +100,6 @@ public class SingleStreamRecordingService extends RecordingService {
 					log.error(
 							"Cannot start single stream recorder for stream {} in session {}: {}. Skipping to next stream being published",
 							p.getPublisherStreamId(), session.getSessionId(), e.getMessage());
-					incompatibleMediaTypePublishers++;
 					recordingStartedCountdown.countDown();
 					continue;
 				}
@@ -121,13 +118,6 @@ public class SingleStreamRecordingService extends RecordingService {
 			log.error("Exception while waiting for state change", e);
 		}
 
-		if (activePublishers == 0 || incompatibleMediaTypePublishers == activePublishers) {
-			// Recording started for a session with some user connected but no publishers
-			// or with no publisher having a compatible media type stream with the recording
-			// configuration. Must create recording root folder for storing metadata archive
-			this.fileWriter.createFolder(this.openviduConfig.getOpenViduRecordingPath() + recording.getId());
-		}
-
 		this.generateRecordingMetadataFile(recording);
 		this.updateRecordingManagerCollections(session, recording);
 		this.sendRecordingStartedNotification(session, recording);

openvidu-server/src/main/java/io/openvidu/server/utils/CustomFileWriter.java

@@ -33,7 +33,7 @@ public class CustomFileWriter {
 		try {
 			this.writeAndCloseOnOutputStreamWriter(new FileOutputStream(filePath), text);
 		} catch (IOException e) {
-			log.error("Couldn't create file {}. Error: ", filePath, e.getMessage());
+			log.error("Couldn't create file {}. Error: {}", filePath, e.getMessage());
 		}
 	}
 
@@ -41,12 +41,18 @@ public class CustomFileWriter {
 		try {
 			this.writeAndCloseOnOutputStreamWriter(new FileOutputStream(filePath, false), text);
 		} catch (IOException e) {
-			log.error("Couldn't overwrite file {}. Error: ", filePath, e.getMessage());
+			log.error("Couldn't overwrite file {}. Error: {}", filePath, e.getMessage());
 		}
 	}
 
-	public boolean createFolder(String path) {
+	public boolean createFolderIfNotExists(String path) {
-		return new File(path).mkdir();
+		File folder = new File(path);
+		if (!folder.exists()) {
+			return folder.mkdir();
+		} else {
+			return false;
+		}
+
 	}
 
 	private void writeAndCloseOnOutputStreamWriter(FileOutputStream fos, String text) throws IOException {